HOME ABOUT SUPPORT US SITES WE LIKE FORUM Search Fanboyplanet.com | Powered by Freefind FANBOY PLANET
ON TV COMICS WRESTLING INTERVIEWS NOW SHOWING GRAB BAG
 
On TV Today's Date:

Smallville
Memorial
original airdate: 04-28-04


It's a Gough & Millar episode, which means I'm not in for any favors. But it also means their own particular brand of continuity bobbles to the surface, bringing us Julian Luthor, Summerholt Institute, Martha's former employment with LuthorCorp, and even a cameo by the iron box Clark once kept Lana's necklace in.

Otherwise, it's flashbacky, over the top, mildly insightful and overall watchable. Perhaps you could say I've lowered my standards, but more I'm just pleased that the revelations herein were the type that last. Odd how that so frequently coincides with Al and Miles's episodes.

I'm also rather pleased about the paucity of Lana Lang, not so much because Kristin Kreuk's performance is still subpar, which it is, but because her plotlines are the type that rev up, peal out and stall when they become inconvenient. (People's 1: Aunt Nell and the anxiety about her dead parents. People's 2: Her biological father, Henry Small. People's 3: Physical therapy following her near-crippling accident.)

Seeking to recover the seven weeks of memory his father wiped out with electroshocks, Lex returns to Summerholt and Dr. Garner to undergo glowy-green immersion therapy. In a longterm sense, this can't work, obviously. The advantages of Lex remembering Lionel's wrongdoings and his grandparents' fate would be far overshadowed by the impossibility of him remembering Clark's secret, or even a shred of it.

Fortunately, this conceit did not focus even the slightest on that period of time; no one-trick pony, the regression therapy unearths mostly memories of Julian Luthor, the triggers for Lex's adolescent psychotic breaks. It proves a slightly longer-term view of the Luthor family dynamic than I'd expected, and provides the flashback John Glover with some marvelous scenes, but why would Lex bury those memories?

Why indeed. Julian and Lillian Luthor both allegedly died of natural causes, SIDS and cancer respectively; although Lex remembers taking the fall for Julian's death, what he finally remembers is whom he took that fall for. His mother, either suffering from mental illness, post-partum depression or possibly just a gripping fear of her husband's parenting tactics, smothered the crying infant with a pillow.

Again Lex takes the blame for another, turning his life down a darker path trying to save the ones he loves most, casting his lot with the demons and figuring he has little to lose. When he reveals as much to Lionel, he realizes what he did lose -- his father's love. Whether he lost it before or after Julian's death, though, is rather up for interpretation.

Michael Rosenbaum improves on his performance yet again, overlaying Lex's unsettled mind with weight and fear and some regret. John Glover is straight up awesome, and oddly affectionate in his scenes with his tortured, lonely yet adoring son.

Clark is singlemindedly against Lex continuing his treatments at Summerholt, even begging Luthor senior to intervene. Lionel takes advantage of that, luring poor Clark to the glowy-green tank to unravel the secrets of his past. Since they don't seem to have a monitor into the brain, and should probably be pretty stymied by an alien MRI, I guess they were sort of hoping Clark would cooperate and narrate his vision of his earliest memory.

Of course, since being outside the meteor-infused water tank made him pass out, that much exposure to kryptonite should probably damn near kill poor Kal-El, but if it had, we'd miss the fanboy interlude made especially for us, with love from Jor-El and Lara.

Why in heaven haven't the Kents manufactured a freaking allergy excuse? In this day and age you have kids who may die if they're in a room with a peanut yet they can't find a Medicalert bracelet for "allergic to green meteor rocks, red meteor rocks, shellfish" stamped on it?

Problem being, we know Clark can't die. There's always a possibility that a tertiary or even secondary character could lose when the dice come up, but not Clark -- not unless the next few episodes are finally going to address the yellow sun in earnest, and since that part of continuity seems to be inconvenient, I don't anticipate it.

Annette O'Toole gets a very rare chance to act the hell out of a scene with Tom Welling, both of them acting rings around the dialogue and actually bringing a tear to my eye without saying a word. (That word, when it's said is, of course, "Lara," -- Martha claims it was Clark's first word, which, well, okay, whatever. It was a nice scene, I'm not going to pick at it.)

Fitting, I suppose, that Gough and Millar can tap the mother-son dynamic just as well, a little early for Mother's Day but still a lovely little present to adoptive mothers everywhere.

The mystery of Pa Kent is slightly solved: he is "in Metropolis" while John Schneider stars in 10.5 on NBC and was preparing to direct next week's episode of Smallville. At least if he dies this season, Ma can pull her weight in the good scenes.

Sarah Stanek

Our Friends:



Official PayPal Seal

Copyrights and trademarks for existing entertainment (film, TV, comics, wrestling) properties are held by their respective owners and are used with permission or for promotional purposes of said properties. All other content ™ and © 2001, 2014 by Fanboy Planet™.
"The Fanboy Planet red planet logo is a trademark of Fanboy Planetâ„¢
If you want to quote us, let us know. We're media whores.
Movies | Comics | Wrestling | OnTV | Guest | Forums | About Us | Sites
Google