Smallville
Don't call him Superboy.
This summer the hot new concept has become "re-imagining." Already
the word should inspire dread in the hearts of genre fans; Planet
of the Apes re-imagined was just so much bad monkey business. The
Musketeer? Please. Thankfully, the one re-imagining that could have
been the scariest turns out to be pretty good. It helps that most attempts
to bring Superman to life have been clumsy. This one isn't.
Smallville marries the Superman mythos with an X-Files
vibe. Which makes sense, as David Nutter directs the pilot (he spent
some time putting Mulder and Scully through their paces). But even with
this darker take on Clark Kent's school days, glimpses of the man he
will become shine through.
Jarring as it may be, the creators of the show have chosen to set
the adventures of Superman when he was a boy in modern day. Twelve years
ago, a meteor shower pounded Smallville, turning it from "the creamed
corn capitol of the world" to "the meteor capitol." The town also suffered
a lot of damage and lost lives, including (off-screen and only inferred)
the Langs. Young Lana (Kristin Kreuk) now lives with her aunt, which
jibes with comics continuity.
Also in the meteor shower, as you all know, comes a spaceship. Its
landing almost kills The Kents (John Schneider and Cynthia Ettinger),
whose truck overturns. But a naked toddler comes to their rescue.
On the other side of town, young Lex Luthor, bored with his father's
attempt to buy out a farm, wanders into a cornfield. There he encounters
a crucified man with a crude red S drawn on his chest, who begs the
boy to help him. Terrified, Luthor runs off, just as meteorites flatten
the entire field. His distraught father (John Glover) finds him shivering
in flattened corn, all his hair gone.
And so one of the most ridiculous aspects of the original Superboy/Lex
Luthor rivalry gets a clever twist. Yes, Lex has lost his hair because
of Clark, indirectly. But neither of them realize it yet. Will it be
enough to send Lex spinning into evil?
|
"I'm Clark Kent and I'm
dreamy. "
|
Hopefully not. The show creators, Alfred Gough and Miles Millar, seem
to have far more up their sleeve. The adult Lex (Michael Rosenbaum),
a few years older than Clark (Tom Welling), is merely careless, in the
way that a child of privilege might well be. The tragedy stems from
his desire to be something different from his ruthless father. Lex really
wants friendship, love, and a place in the community. But growing up
a Luthor means he has no idea how to attain those things. Pride and
frustration may lead to evil.
By contrast, Clark could easily have it all. Broodingly good-looking
(and in true WB casting fashion, far older than 15), intelligent, the
only thing that holds Clark back is his growing realization that he's
not like other men. To make his apparent nerd-dom believable, the writers
have provided a kryptonite necklace: whenever Clark approaches Lana,
the glowing stone around her neck causes him to grow weak, trip, stammer,
and feel like he's going to throw up.
In a moment of destiny, Lex accidentally hits Clark while swerving
in his Porsche; both fly off of a bridge and into the river. Naturally,
Clark saves Lex, forming the basis for a tentative friendship.
And what of the guy crucified in the cornfield? That would be telling.
Suffice to say that that scene comes back to haunt some citizens of
Smallville, and establishes the hook of the show. With all that kryptonite
radiation around, some people are going to suffer some changes. While
we dare not mention the word "supervillains," they will run through
the series in all but spandex.
The production seems to want to have it both ways. Obviously, you
have to believe a man can fly from the outset, though he may only be
leaping the fabled 1/8 of a mile during the series. Welling has publicly
distanced himself from being labeled "Superman." Though the creators
are trying to take as realistic as possible a look at the character,
they still make sly allusions to the larger DC Universe. Barry Allen
makes an appearance in a newspaper article, and rumor has it that they
will also allude to Green Arrow in a later episode. (But then right
now isn't everybody trying to work in Green Arrow?)
Still, superpowers make the characters uncomfortable. Lex thinks he
may have imagined them in Clark, but invulnerability troubles Clark
himself. Like any high school freshman, he wants to be normal. It's
a sticking point in the conception, because he also knows full well
that with his super-strength, he could be a great football player, and
has no problem racing through the cornfields to beat the schoolbus.
Yet he survives getting knocked through a bridge and has a fit. Go figure.
The show makes an interesting choice in giving Clark a tremendous
sense of guilt over what has happened to Smallville. He blames himself
for the death of the Langs, and feels that he has to fix things.
At first, this motivation seems at odds with the Superman we know.
But Clark is still young, and of course takes things personally. With
time, we can hope that he grows to understand that his powers are a
blessing to share with the world. When the time comes to be Superman,
he should do it because it's the right thing, not because he has penance
to do.
Overall, the show has been well cast. Rosenbaum plays Lex with an
openness tinged by unknowing arrogance, echoing Glover as his father.
Relative newcomer Kreuk has little to do right now but be cute and puzzled,
but she does it well. The real surprise comes in Schneider as Pa Kent;
this Duke boy has turned out to be the perfect incarnation of the dad
we'd all like to have, but even better-looking.
|
"First I
shall take everything Cynthia Ettinger loves and then I will
kill her! Muhahaha!"
|
As Martha Kent, Ettinger shows appropriate concern, but by the time
this pilot makes it to air, she will have been replaced. Her few scenes
will easily have been re-shot with Annette O'Toole, a good choice. It's
not that Ettinger sucks; she is simply too young. She looks like she
undergoes age make-up to be Clark's mother, which looks silly next to
Schneider. O'Toole is the right age while still being the attractive
mom television demands.
One other crucial "re-imagining" for the show, and we thank the producers
for it, is that the rocket that brings Kal-El to Earth finally looks
alien. Not a single House of El marking upon it. This Clark Kent will
earn and create the "S" shield all by himself.
Smallville sets its mark by respecting the legend without being
slavish to it. And it's a heck of a lot better than Lois and Clark.
Discuss
this and more in the Fanboy forums.