Falls
Count Anywhere
12-31-07
|
I
know...you've been waiting.
|
The
Annual Christopher J. Garcia Awards for Outstanding Achievement
in the Field of Wrestling Excellence
This
has been a rough year. The year started out strong with
a good Rumble and a Mania that was nearly off the charts.
TNA was doing good numbers, and they’ve only sagged
for brief periods, and UFC was having hot stuff all over
the place.
Then
the Bad hit.
For
wrestling as a whole, it was Chris Benoit. The WWE took
a pretty serious ratings hit as the initial interest in
seeing how things played out faded away. The Benoit murder-suicide
was without question the most damaging thing that has ever
happened to the world of wrestling. The questions came and
almost never got any good answers. The WWE had parts of
its business exposed that it never wanted to be seen. But
worst of all was the death of three people.
There
were other passings this year. The Fabulous Moolah left
us after 84 long years. She was a controversial figure in
the history of wrestling and one of the best remembered
women in the sport due to her time in the 1980s. We lost
Sensational Sherri, an important part of Woman’s wrestling
in the 1980s and a great manager, too. Bam Bam Bigelow,
a star in every company he went to at some level and one
of the best big men in history. Karl Gotch. John Kronus.
Bryan Crush Adams. While it is a year that will be remembered
for the one massive passing, there was no shortage of others.
The
steroid scandal that the Benoit investigation brought out
was coupled with the scandals of MMA fighters using roids.
The suspensions were mired in charges that the tests were
catching the results of legal supplements and not actual
roid use. That’s a possibility, but who knows for
sure? The baseball investigations didn’t help, either,
and the WWE’s testing is found to be highly questionable.
The scandal continues, though the Congress isn’t planning
hearings at this time, which is a good thing.
There
were injuries, including losing most of the WWE’s
top starts, including John Cena, Edge, Lashley, The Undertaker,
Kennedy, Shawn Michaels, HHH, you name it, they went down.
While Cena’s probably hurt the most, the lack of depth
was very obvious.
OK,
now some awards...
The
Trish Stratus Award for Woman of the Year- TNA's Gail Kim
(Last Year’s Winner- Trish Stratus)
They’re building the woman’s division around
her, but they’re making her work and she’s had
some good matches. I’ve always thought she was pretty
good. Beth Phoenix is second, and if she’d been around
all-year, she’d have won. Mickie James and ODB both
tie for third. I miss Trish.
Best
on Interviews- Santino Marella
(Last Year’s Winner: Jim Mitchell)
Santino isn’t great in the ring, but the guy can talk
and his interviews have been really good. He’s made
me want to claw his eyes out a few times but when he talks,
he gets himself over. I totally love a heel Santino, though
the only reason he won is that it was a weak year for Mic
work. Second goes to Shawn Michaels, who had some really
good ones but slacked a bit and was gone for a good while.
Gotta give third to John Cena, though he could have won
if he’d been around all year.
Most
Misused Wrestler of the Year- Samoa Joe
If you’d told me that Samoa Joe would mean almost
nothing at this point in 2007, I wouldn’t believe
you. It’s sadly true and that’s a shame. While
Shelton Benjamin was never pushed hard, Joe was, but in
ways that didn’t get him over as a monster any longer.
Here’s a guy who could have been the biggest thing
in wrestling but was ruined by tit-for-tat booking, being
passed up in favour of bigger and older names, and just
flat-out poorly booked. Shelton is second and Cody Rhodes
is third. There are a lot of names that I thought of, including
Ric Flair, London and Kendrick, Chris Daniels and AJ Styles.
Tag
Team of the Year- Rated RKO
(Last year’s winners- KENTA and Marifuji)
No question that this was a weak year for tags, but the
Rated RKO guys did really well working with DX and were
the top heel team at the time. The guys also did some really
good interviews and felt like an important team. Kendrick
and London are second and third is The Briscoes in Ring
of Honor.
The
Lou Thesz Award for Good Wrestling- Bryan Danielson
(Last Year’s winner- KENTA)
There’s no one who works better matches that Danielson
and his work is being noticed by the bigs who won’t
sign him. His matches with Morishima were great, but so
were the ones with KENTA and others. He’s a huge talent
and eventually he’ll end up as a player in one of
the bigs. KENTA is second and Morishima is third. No one
in the WWE was really at the level of any of these guys,
and TNA’s booking kept a lot of guys from shining
in-ring.
MMA
Show of the Year- The Ultimate Fighter IV Finale
There’s never been a better up-and-down show than
this. Every fight felt important and two of them were Fight
of the Year level. A star was confirmed and several fights
had people talking. I’m not sure which is second and
which is third, but the Shamrock vs. Baroni Strikeforce
show and the Couture vs. Gonzaga show for the UFC both come
right up there.
Wrestling
Show of the Year- WrestleMania
(Last Year’s Winner- Glory by Honor)
Well, what can you say? Mania was a huge highlight with
some great matches and some fun stuff. It was a wonderful
show that was well-booked and had the aura that the best
wrestling shows always seem to have. Ring of Honor gets
the nod for second and third with the September 15th match
from the Frontier Fieldhouse featuring Danielson vs. Morishima
and the Driven PPV where Kenta and Danielson had such a
great match. I also want to give the Shimmer Title Tournament
and the Pro Wrestling NOAH show where Kenta Kobashi came
back honorable mentions.
Feud
of the Year- Shamrock vs. Baroni
(Last year’s winner: Edge vs. Cena)
Well, it was short, and the match itself was really good,
but Shamrock and Baroni had a huge deal going and got interest
in Strikeforce huge. I’d say they built it better
than anything else going this year. DX vs. Rated RKO is
second and the final slot goes to Morishima vs. Danielson
in RoH. Not a great year for feuds.
MMA
Match of the Year- Frank Shamrock vs. Phil Baroni
There’s no other match this year that had heat going
in and that delivered. Both guys went all out, as is obvious
by the pain they put themselves through fighting the match.
It was great to watch and it’s one of those matches
I’ll be talking about for years. Better than the Shamrock
vs. Ortiz match from 1999 that really turned me into a fan.
Second will have to be the Roger Huerta over Clay Guida
match from a couple of weeks back. It was a great match
that felt like it mattered. I’ll then say Randy Couture
over Gonzaga as number three.
Wrestling
Match of the Year- Danielson vs. Morishima from RoH
This was the match that I was most excited about. Morishima
is awesome. Danielson is awesome. The match was great with
all sorts of heat and a legit-looking finish that made use
of the fact that Danielson had a legit eye injury caused
by Morishima and they had an agreement that Morishima wouldn’t
attack the eye. Beautiful story-telling. I’m going
the Rumble second because it told a good story and was exciting
and the Batista vs. UT Hell in the Cell third as I thought
it was a masterfully booked match. Nothing from TNA seems
to come close this year.
MMA
Fighter of the Year- Randy Couture
Sure he quit, but the guy still had two of the best, most
exciting matches of the year and proved that you can still
go when you’re over 40. He beat Gonzaga which was
a wonderful fight and he was the champ when he took off.
I still think he’d have taken either Quint Jackson
or Mirko Cro Cop. Hell, he’d have beated Fedor if
they fought! Second will have to be Rampage Jackson for
beating a solid Liddell and keeping his belt this long.
Cung Le is third for the fine fighting he’s been doing
in Strikeforce.
Wrestling
of the Year- Morishima
(Last Year’s Winner- Edge)
Here’s a rarity: a Japanese wrestler who gets over
with an American crowd by not playing the xenophobic race
card. Morishima wasn’t taken to early, but after a
while as RoH champ, he got into the groove and became a
favorite. His matches were solid with the likes of Bryan
Danielson and Nigel McGuinness. He did great things in Japan,
too. The guy is the future of Japanese wrestling. Second
is harder, but I’m going with John Cena who really
worked hard and tough and though he finished the year on
the DL, was the biggest draw all year. Third will be Undertaker
for having such great matches with Batista and for having
all that heat even after he came off an injury.
|